Epidemiology of appendicectomy
in primary sclerosing cholangitis and ulcerative colitis: its influence
on the clinical behaviour of these diseases
T H J Florin1, N Pandeya2 and G L Radford-Smith3
1 Brisbane IBD Research Group, and University
of Queensland Department of Medicine and Mater Health Services,
South Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
2 Brisbane IBD Research Group, and Population Health Unit, Queensland
Institute of Medical Research, Queensland, Australia
3 Brisbane IBD Research Group, and Department of Gastroenterology,
Royal Brisbane Hospital, Brisbane, Australia
Correspondence to:
Associate Professor T Florin
UQ Department of Medicine, Mater Health Services’ Adult Hospital,
South Brisbane, Queensland 4101, Australia; t.florin@uq.edu.au
Background and aims: Appendicectomy
and smoking are environmental factors that are known to influence
ulcerative colitis (UC). The phenotype of UC is different in patients
with coexistent primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). This study
investigates the interaction of appendicectomy and PSC on the epidemiology
and clinical behaviour of colitis.
Methods: Patients were from the Brisbane
IBD Research Group database. Controls were from the Australian twin
registry. Seventy eight PSC-inflammatory bowel disease (PSC-IBD)
patients, 12 pure PSC, and 294 UC patients were matched with 1466
controls by sex and birth cohort that comprised randomly selected
twins from each twin pair. The effects of appendicectomy, smoking,
or PSC on the onset of disease, disease extent, disease severity
(as identified by immunosuppression-colectomy or liver transplant),
and disease related complications (high grade dysplasia, colorectal
cancer, or cholangiocarcinoma) were investigated using univariate
and multiple logistic regression analyses.
Results: PSC-IBD patients had a more
extensive colitis than UC patients (p<0.0001) but required less
immunosuppression (p = 0.007), which was independent of disease
extent. They were more likely to have high grade dysplasia or colorectal
cancer (p = 0.029) than UC patients. Appendicectomy rates in the
PSC groups were not different from the control groups (p = 0.72,
0.76), which was in sharp contrast with UC where the rate was four
times less (p = 0.0001). Prior appendicectomy appeared to be associated
with an approximate five year delay in the onset of intestinal (PSC-IBD
or UC) or hepatic (PSC) disease, which was independent of smoking.
Appendicectomy did not independently alter the extent or severity
of disease in PSC. In contrast, prior appendicectomy in UC was associated
with more extensive disease but with a lesser requirement for immunosuppression
or colectomy for the treatment of colitis (p = 0.004). There were
trends for high grade dysplasia or colorectal cancer with appendicectomy
in both PSC-IBD and UC. Although these trends were not statistically
significant, colorectal cancer appeared more frequent with appendicectomy
in a meta-analysis of the available UC data from this and another
Australian study.
Conclusions: In contradistinction
to UC, appendicectomy did not significantly influence the prevalence
of the PSC groups, or the extent of colitis in PSC-IBD, but as with
UC, did appear to delay their onset. The extensive milder colitis,
which is characteristic of PSC-IBD, relates to other poorly understood
factors. Further prospective studies are required to determine any
influence of appendicectomy on the extent of colitis in IBD and
an associated dysplasia or colorectal cancer.
|